Criterion 3001 requires the application to be validly made within 28 days after the "relevant day". For most people the relevant day is the last day they held a substantive visa. If you last entered Australia unlawfully after that, it is the day you entered. If your last substantive visa was cancelled and the Tribunal later set the cancellation aside, the 28 days can run from the day you are taken to have been notified of the Tribunal's decision.
Schedule 3: What Happens If You Apply for a Partner Visa When Your Visa Has Expired
Schedule 3 applies when you lodge an onshore partner visa (subclass 820) without holding a substantive visa.
That covers people whose student, visitor or work visa has ended, people who hold only a bridging visa, and people with no visa at all.
A Schedule 3 problem does not mean automatic refusal. The Minister can set the Schedule 3 criteria aside if satisfied there are compelling reasons, and tribunals have done that in published decisions. Nobody is guaranteed that outcome.
This guide covers who Schedule 3 applies to, what the criteria say, how the compelling reasons waiver has been applied, and what the review options are after a refusal.
What Schedule 3 is.
Schedule 3 is part of the Migration Regulations 1994. Its title is "Additional criteria applicable to unlawful non-citizens and certain bridging visa holders". It contains five criteria, numbered 3001 to 3005.
The criteria only apply where a visa subclass says they do. For the subclass 820 partner visa, that is clause 820.211(2)(d). If you do not hold a substantive visa when you apply, clause 820.211(2)(d)(ii) requires you to satisfy Schedule 3 criteria 3001, 3003 and 3004, "unless the Minister is satisfied that there are compelling reasons for not applying those criteria".
You have to satisfy all three criteria, not just one of them. If you cannot, the visa can only be granted if the Minister (in practice a Department officer, or the Tribunal on review) is satisfied there are compelling reasons for not applying them.
What each Schedule 3 criterion says:
Lodging within 28 days satisfies criterion 3001 only. Lodging in time is not enough by itself. You must still satisfy every part of criterion 3004, including that you are without a substantive visa because of factors beyond your control and that there are compelling reasons for granting the visa. A visa simply running out does not show factors beyond your control. If you cannot satisfy 3004, you need the waiver. Both routes need compelling reasons.
When Schedule 3 applies and when it does not.
Schedule 3 applies if you lodge the onshore 820 partner visa and you are not the holder of a substantive visa when you apply.
Section 5 of the Migration Act defines a substantive visa as a visa other than a bridging visa, a criminal justice visa, or an enforcement visa. So:
A bridging visa keeps you lawfully in Australia, but it is not a substantive visa. If your last substantive visa has ended and you hold only a bridging visa when you lodge the 820, Schedule 3 applies to you.
Some former Prospective Marriage (subclass 300) holders without a substantive visa are assessed under other subclauses that have no Schedule 3 requirement: clause 820.211(5) (married the partner they came to marry, and stopped holding a substantive visa after the marriage) and clause 820.211(9) (the relationship has ended and there is family violence or a child arrangement).
Schedule 3 does not apply to the offshore 309 partner visa. The 309 criteria do not refer to Schedule 3. That is why applicants who cannot get past Schedule 3 often consider leaving Australia and applying for the 309.
The compelling reasons waiver.
If you do not satisfy criteria 3001, 3003 and 3004, the visa can still be granted if the Minister is satisfied that there are compelling reasons for not applying those criteria. This is a discretion. No set of facts guarantees it will be exercised in your favour.
The Migration Regulations do not define "compelling reasons". In Babicci v MIMIA [2005] FCAFC 77 the Full Federal Court considered a similar phrase, "compelling circumstances", in a different regulation about sponsorship limits. The court said "the circumstances must be so powerful that they lead the decision-maker to make a positive finding" that the rule should be waived. In that case the Tribunal accepted the sponsor's ill health and psychological problems were real and still found they were not compelling. Tribunals deciding Schedule 3 cases cite Babicci for the standard, for example Chau [2021] AATA 1500.
The Waensila decision.
From 2002, decision-makers followed Boakye-Danquah v MIMIA [2002] FCA 438, where a single Federal Court judge held that compelling reasons had to be assessed on the circumstances at the time of the visa application. Anything that happened after lodgement was left out.
On 11 March 2016 the Full Federal Court decided Waensila v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 32. All three judges allowed the appeal and overruled Boakye-Danquah on this point. The court held that the decision-maker is not confined to circumstances that existed when the application was made and can take into account the circumstances at the time of the decision. Mr Waensila's application had taken more than three years to decide, and in that time his wife had come to depend on him for her health needs.
So circumstances that arise after lodgement can be put forward and considered. That includes a child born during processing, a sponsor's illness, or a relationship that has become long-standing. One of the judges said the same applies to circumstances "whether they favour the visa applicant or not", so later events that count against you can be considered too.
The Migration Act lets an applicant give the Department more information at any time before a decision is made, and the Department must have regard to it (section 55). If something relevant changes while you wait, you can tell the Department.
Examples that have been accepted as compelling.
These are examples, not rules. Two come from the Explanatory Statement that introduced the waiver in 1996, which the Full Federal Court quoted in Waensila. The Explanatory Statement said the waiver was expected to be used only for reasons of a 'strongly compassionate' nature and gave these two as examples. The rest come from published tribunal decisions. Each case was decided on its own evidence, and the same facts will not always produce the same result.
- Australian citizen children from the relationship. This is one of the two examples in the 1996 Explanatory Statement. In 0903322 [2010] MRTA 342 the applicant had an eight-month-old Australian citizen daughter when he applied, and the Tribunal accepted it was in her best interests for him to stay.
- A long-standing relationship. The other Explanatory Statement example is a relationship that has existed for two years or longer. In Chau [2021] AATA 1500 the Tribunal treated a five-year relationship as a compelling reason.
- The sponsor's dependence on the applicant, supported by medical evidence. In Chau a psychiatrist's report said the sponsor's mental health would deteriorate if the couple were separated. In V06/00604 [2006] MRTA 465 the Tribunal accepted that the sponsor's long-standing depression meant the applicant's absence would affect him well beyond an ordinary temporary separation.
- The effect on the sponsor's own children. In Clester [2003] MRTA 8788 the Tribunal accepted that the applicant's absence would have a significant adverse effect on the sponsor's two Australian citizen children, who were in her day-to-day care.
- How the applicant came to be without a substantive visa. In Clester the Tribunal also took into account that the applicant had applied for a further visa before his last one expired and had not deliberately become a person without a substantive visa.
What has not been enough.
- A genuine relationship with nothing more. Tribunals apply MIMA v Dunne [1999] FCA 204 to mean that compelling reasons must be something more than meeting the basic requirements for the visa. Departmental policy quoted in Clester said the same: a genuine relationship, without other factors, would not be compelling enough.
- Sympathetic circumstances that are real but not powerful enough. In Babicci (a sponsorship-limit case, not a Schedule 3 case) the Tribunal accepted the sponsor's ailments, psychological problems and other personal circumstances were real and still found they were not compelling. The Full Federal Court found no error in that.
- Claims with no independent evidence. In V06/00604 the Tribunal wrote to the applicant that she had given no objective evidence of her sponsor's condition. The Tribunal accepted the claim after a letter from his treating doctor was provided.
How a Schedule 3 case proceeds.
The usual order of events:
What happens if the 820 is refused.
After a refusal there are three options. A second onshore partner application is generally not one of them: a person without a substantive visa who has been refused a partner visa since last entering Australia cannot make a valid onshore partner application (Schedule 1, item 1124B).
Apply to the Administrative Review Tribunal
The Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) replaced the Administrative Appeals Tribunal on 14 October 2024. You must apply within 28 days after the day you are notified of the refusal, or within 14 days if you are in immigration detention when notified (section 347 of the Migration Act). The Tribunal cannot extend these limits. You must be in Australia when you apply. The fee is $3,727, reduced by 50% in cases of financial hardship, and it must be paid before the deadline.
The ART describes its job as "taking a fresh look at the facts, law and policy relating to the original decision" and considering any new information. Tribunals apply Waensila, so compelling circumstances that arose after the Department's refusal can be put to the Tribunal.
A Bridging C ends 35 days after the refusal if you do not apply for review. If you apply to the Tribunal in time, Home Affairs says it lets you stay until the review is decided, and the Regulations end it 35 days after the Tribunal's decision. A Bridging E can have different end dates. Check VEVO.
Leave Australia and lodge offshore (the 309)
Schedule 3 is not a criterion for the 309 partner visa, which is applied for from outside Australia.
The costs of this option:
- A bridging visa that does not allow re-entry ends when you leave Australia. A Tribunal review application can only be made while you are in Australia.
- You are separated from your partner while the 309 is processed. Home Affairs' processing time guide in November 2026 showed half of 309 applications decided within 21 months and 90% within 35 months.
- Public interest criteria 4013 and 4014 are not criteria for the 309, but they are criteria for many temporary visas, including the visitor visa. Criterion 4014 affects a person who left Australia as an unlawful non-citizen or as the holder of a Bridging C, D or E visa, with exceptions tied to the 28 days after a substantive visa ended. Criterion 4013 affects a person whose visa was cancelled on certain grounds. For three years, a visa with these criteria can only be granted if there are compelling or compassionate circumstances. This can stop you visiting your partner in Australia while the 309 is processed.
- The 309 has its own return criteria for people who have been deported or removed from Australia or had a visa cancelled on character grounds.
Get advice from a registered migration agent or lawyer before you leave Australia, because your bridging visa ends when you leave and you cannot apply to the Tribunal from outside Australia.
Judicial review or ministerial intervention
If the ART affirms the refusal, you can apply to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) for judicial review within 35 days of the date of the Tribunal's decision. The court can extend that time if it is satisfied this is necessary in the interests of the administration of justice. The court does not re-decide whether you should get the visa. It decides whether the Tribunal made a jurisdictional error, as the Full Federal Court found in Waensila.
After an ART decision, the Minister has a personal power under section 351 of the Migration Act to substitute a more favourable decision if the Minister thinks it is in the public interest. Section 417, which older material mentions, has been repealed. The Minister has no duty to consider a request.
Evidence that supports a waiver request.
These follow from the criteria and from the tribunal decisions above. None of them guarantees a waiver.
- Children. Birth certificates, citizenship evidence, and records that show the child's life in Australia and your role in it, such as school or childcare enrolments and medical records.
- The length of the relationship. Evidence of when the relationship began and that it has continued. The 1996 Explanatory Statement example is a relationship of two years or longer.
- Sponsor dependence. Reports from the treating psychiatrist, psychologist or GP that describe the condition and what separation would mean. In V06/00604 the Tribunal raised the lack of objective evidence before a doctor's letter was provided.
- How you came to be without a substantive visa. Criterion 3004 asks whether this was because of factors beyond your control. Give a dated account and the documents that support it, such as Department correspondence, medical records, or records of an earlier application.
- Compliance with your last visa. Criterion 3004 asks whether you substantially complied with the conditions of your last substantive visa and any bridging visa after it (a breach that exists only because the visa ended does not count). If you did, say so and show it.
- Family violence, where it is part of the history. The Regulations do not limit what can be a compelling reason, so family violence that explains how you lost your visa status can be put forward with evidence such as police reports or court orders. This guide does not cite a published decision on this point. The separate family violence provisions for partner visas deal with a different situation, where the relationship with the sponsor has ended.
Problems that come up in Schedule 3 cases.
These follow from the criteria and the decisions above.
- Relying on the relationship alone. Being in a genuine relationship is a requirement for every partner visa. Tribunals have said compelling reasons must be something more.
- No independent evidence. A statement that your partner depends on you carries little weight without medical or other professional evidence.
- Losing visa status through your own choices. Criterion 3004 asks whether you are without a substantive visa because of factors beyond your control. In Chau the Tribunal noted that Department policy directs decision-makers to how the applicant became unlawful.
- A long period without a visa and no attempt to fix it. In Chau the delegate gave this great weight and the Tribunal said it viewed almost four years of unlawfulness in a grave light, before deciding the sponsor's circumstances outweighed it.
- Breaches of earlier visa conditions. Criterion 3004 asks about substantial compliance with the conditions of your last substantive visa and any later bridging visa.
- Inconsistent accounts. Tribunals make findings about whether the applicant and sponsor are credible. In Clester the Tribunal noted conflicting evidence about when the couple began living together and decided that point against them, although it found them credible overall.
Common situations and how the rules apply.
We cannot tell you whether a waiver would be granted in your situation. This is how the rules apply to six common situations.
A student visa holder whose visa is about to expire
If you lodge the 820 while you still hold the student visa, you hold a substantive visa at the time of application and Schedule 3 does not apply. If you lodge after the student visa has ended, Schedule 3 applies.
A bridging visa holder from an earlier application
If your last substantive visa has ended and you hold only a bridging visa from an earlier onshore application, Schedule 3 applies because a bridging visa is not a substantive visa. The 28 days in criterion 3001 run from the last day you held the substantive visa, not from the bridging visa. If the earlier application was refused, section 48 of the Migration Act limits which visas you can apply for in Australia. The partner visa is on the permitted list, with extra requirements at lodgement.
An applicant with no visa and Australian citizen children
Australian citizen children from the relationship are one of the two examples of compelling reasons in the 1996 Explanatory Statement, and tribunals have accepted them in published decisions. The outcome still depends on the evidence in the individual case.
An applicant who lost visa status because of family violence
The Regulations do not limit what can count as a compelling reason, and criterion 3004 asks whether you are without a substantive visa because of factors beyond your control. Family violence that explains the loss of status can be put forward with evidence. The family violence provisions for partner visas are separate from Schedule 3.
An applicant who lodges within 28 days of their visa ending
Lodging within 28 days after the last day you held a substantive visa satisfies criterion 3001 only. Lodging in time is not enough by itself. You must still satisfy every part of criterion 3004, including that you are without a substantive visa because of factors beyond your control and that there are compelling reasons for granting the visa. A visa simply running out does not show factors beyond your control. If you cannot satisfy 3004, you need the waiver. Both routes need compelling reasons.
An applicant without a visa for several years and no clear compelling facts
The waiver can still be considered, but the published examples above involve children, long relationships or documented dependence. Applicants in this position often look at applying offshore for the 309, where Schedule 3 is not a criterion. Leaving has its own consequences, set out above.
These are illustrations, not recommendations.
Frequently asked.
Can I apply for a partner visa in Australia if my visa has expired?
Often yes, but there are limits. Holding a substantive visa is not a requirement for making a valid 820 application, and Schedule 3 is assessed when the Department decides whether to grant the visa. If any visa you have held since you last entered Australia carried a No further stay condition (such as 8503), you cannot make a valid 820 application in Australia unless that condition has been waived, even after that visa has ended (section 46(1A) of the Migration Act). If you have been refused a partner visa since you last entered Australia and you do not hold a substantive visa, you cannot make a valid onshore partner application. If you have had another visa refused or cancelled since you last entered, extra documents are required at lodgement. Lodging does not mean the visa will be granted.
What are compelling and compassionate circumstances for a partner visa?
The wording in the partner visa criteria is "compelling reasons", and the Regulations do not define it. In Babicci the Full Federal Court said, about a similar phrase, that the circumstances must be so powerful that they lead the decision-maker to waive the rule. The 1996 Explanatory Statement gave two examples: Australian citizen children from the relationship, and a relationship of two years or longer. Tribunals have also accepted a sponsor's medically documented dependence on the applicant. These are examples, not rules, and none guarantees a waiver. A genuine relationship with nothing more has not been enough.
Does Schedule 3 apply if I am on a bridging visa?
Yes, if the bridging visa is the only visa you hold. A bridging visa is not a substantive visa under the Migration Act. You must satisfy Schedule 3 criteria 3001, 3003 and 3004 unless the Minister is satisfied there are compelling reasons for not applying them.
What is the Waensila decision and why does it matter?
Waensila v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 32 is a Full Federal Court decision of 11 March 2016. It held that a decision-maker assessing compelling reasons is not confined to the circumstances at the time of application and can take into account the circumstances at the time of decision. It overruled Boakye-Danquah [2002] FCA 438, which had said the opposite. Circumstances that arise during processing, such as the birth of a child or a sponsor's illness, can be considered.
Can I leave Australia to lodge a 309 if my 820 is refused?
Yes. Schedule 3 is not a criterion for the 309. The costs are that a bridging visa without re-entry rights ends when you leave, you cannot apply to the Tribunal from outside Australia, and you are separated during processing (in November 2026, Home Affairs showed half of 309 applications decided within 21 months and 90% within 35 months). Public interest criteria 4013 and 4014 are not 309 criteria, but they can block temporary visas such as a visitor visa for three years.
How long do I have to apply to the Tribunal if my 820 is refused?
28 days after the day you are notified of the decision, or 14 days if you are in immigration detention when notified (section 347 of the Migration Act). The Tribunal cannot extend the time. The fee is $3,727, with a 50% reduction for financial hardship, and must be paid before the deadline. Your decision letter states your review rights and deadline.
Will the Department refuse my 820 because of Schedule 3?
Not automatically. The Department must first decide whether you satisfy criteria 3001, 3003 and 3004 and, if you do not, whether there are compelling reasons for not applying them. It may ask you for more information, but a refusal can come without a request first. If the visa is refused, you can apply to the Tribunal for review.
Does Schedule 3 apply to the 309 offshore partner visa?
No. The criteria for the 309 do not refer to Schedule 3. The 309 is applied for from outside Australia.
What is the difference between a substantive visa and a bridging visa?
Section 5 of the Migration Act defines a substantive visa as a visa other than a bridging visa, a criminal justice visa, or an enforcement visa. Student, visitor, working holiday and skilled visas are substantive. Bridging visas are not. If a bridging visa is the only visa you hold, you do not hold a substantive visa, even though you are lawfully in Australia.
Summary.
Schedule 3 applies to an onshore 820 applicant who does not hold a substantive visa. The applicant must satisfy criteria 3001, 3003 and 3004, or the Minister must be satisfied there are compelling reasons for not applying them. Lodging within 28 days of the last day you held a substantive visa satisfies 3001 only. You must still satisfy every part of 3004, including that you are without a substantive visa because of factors beyond your control and that there are compelling reasons for granting the visa, or obtain the waiver. Both routes need compelling reasons. The Regulations do not define compelling reasons. Published examples include Australian citizen children, a relationship of two years or longer, and a sponsor's medically documented dependence, and none of them guarantees a waiver. Since Waensila, circumstances up to the time of decision can be considered. After a refusal you have 28 days to apply to the ART. Applying offshore for the 309 avoids Schedule 3 but means leaving Australia and waiting out the processing time. Get a migration agent or lawyer involved early.
This is general information about Schedule 3, not advice on your situation. Schedule 3 outcomes are fact-specific and decisions turn on the strength of evidence. If you are facing a Schedule 3 issue, find a registered migration agent before lodging. For the related decision about whether to apply onshore or offshore in the first place, see our 820 vs 309 comparison guide. For the broader relationship evidence picture, see our genuine relationship evidence guide.
More guides.
820 vs 309: Onshore or Offshore Australian Partner Visa?
The onshore (820) and offshore (309) partner visas cost the same and lead to a permanent visa. They differ in where you apply and what you can do while you wait.
The Genuine Relationship Test for Australian Partner Visas: What IMMI Looks For
How an Australian partner visa relationship is assessed: the legal definitions, the four groups of matters in the Migration Regulations, the evidence Home Affairs asks for, and five requirements to check before lodging.
General information about how Schedule 3 works, not advice on your situation. Schedule 3 cases are fact-specific and outcomes depend on evidence, timing, and individual circumstances. If you are facing a Schedule 3 issue, talk to a registered migration agent or migration lawyer as soon as you can. Find one at mara.gov.au.